Melissa Fumero Birdie Actor Aja Naomi King Catherine Actor Ben Rappaport Brett Actor AnnaSophia Robb Alice Actor Matthew Davis Joel Actor Alexander Hodge Doug Actor Nancy Travis Patty Actor Felix Wolfe Ford Actor Nora Zehetner Melissa Guest Star Josh Ventura Connor Guest Star Jocko Sims Tucker Guest Star Jennifer Irwin Marilyn Guest Star Saamer Usmani Gary Guest Star Daniella Alonso Misty Guest Star Christian Finlayson Peyton Guest Star Carrie Walrond Hood Olivia Guest Star Lauren Burns Ivy Guest Star Jason Francisco Blue Principal Andrews Guest Star Gavin Borders Zach Guest Star Terryn Westbrook Diane Guest Star Ahmed Lucan Max Guest Star Jamie Moore Ron Guest Star Lindsay Rootare Preppy Wife Guest Star Teryn Simmons Waitress Guest Star Jessica Arinella Heather Guest Star Dayo Abanikanda Logan Guest Star Lainey Knowles Zoe Guest Star Ava Threat Kid Guest Star Jenna Bans Executive Producer, Writer Bill Krebs Executive Producer, Writer Casey Kyber Executive Producer Maggie Kiley Director