Geoff Stults Tommy Conroy Actor Sam Neill Merritt Grieves Actor Lauren German Henley Boone Actor Steven Weber John Haplin Actor Amy Acker Rachel Conroy Actor Sarah Gadon Georgia Bravin Actor Robert Wisdom Roger Hobbs Actor Jay Paulson Eli "Root Beer" Rogers Actor Ben Schnetzer Andrew Haplin Actor M.C. Gainey Guest Star Abraham Benrubi Guest Star Linda Kash Guest Star Lynne Griffin Guest Star Natalie Brown Guest Star Joanna Douglas Guest Star Wendy Lyon Guest Star Dan Petronijevic Guest Star Maxwell McCabe-Lokos Guest Star Steve Arbuckle Guest Star Matt Hopkins Guest Star Marcia Bennett Guest Star Diane Gordon Guest Star Anna Ferguson Guest Star Deborah Grover Guest Star Greg Bryk Guest Star Sophia Ewaniuk Guest Star Boyd Banks Guest Star Kedar Brown Guest Star Brittany Kay Guest Star Luke Aquilina Guest Star Brad Borbridge Guest Star Cassidi Hoag Guest Star Josh Appelbaum Executive Producer, Writer Andre Nemec Executive Producer, Writer Scott Rosenberg Executive Producer, Writer Gary Fleder Director