Elaine Cassidy Abby Mills Actor Christopher Gorham Henry Dunn Actor Katie Cassidy Trish Wellington Actor Cameron Richardson Chloe Carter Actor Adam Campbell Cal Vandeusen Actor C.J. Thomason Jimmy Mance Actor Jim Beaver Sheriff Charlie Mills Actor Matt Barr Christopher "Sully" Sullivan Actor Amber Borycki Beth Barrington Actor Richard Burgi Thomas Wellington Actor Dean Chekvala J.D. Dunn Actor Ben Cotton Shane Pierce Actor Beverley Elliott Maggie Krell Actor Chris Gauthier Malcolm Ross Actor Harry Hamlin Uncle Marty Dunn Actor Gina Holden Shea Allen Actor Ali Liebert Nikki Bolton Actor Brandon Jay McLaren Danny Brooks Actor Claudette Mink Katherine Wellington Actor Sean Rogerson Joel Booth Actor Anna Mae Willis Kelly Seaver Actor Cassandra Sawtell Madison Allen Actor Sarah Smyth Lucy Daramour Actor Victor Webster Hunter Jennings Actor Sarah-Jane Redmond Sarah Mills Guest Star Ava Hughes Young Abby Guest Star Alex Ferris Young Henry Guest Star Ryan Grantham Young J.D. Guest Star Adrian Hough Joseph Dunn Guest Star Nadine Wright Cheryl Dunn Guest Star Kwesi Ameyaw FBI Agent Hanson Guest Star Barbara Kottmeier Agent Ana Perez Guest Star Peter Ciuffa Man in Seattle Guest Star