Rachel Bilson Dr. Zoe Hart Actor Jaime King Lemon Breeland Actor Wilson Bethel Wade Kinsella Actor Cress Williams Lavon Hayes Actor Scott Porter George Tucker Actor Tim Matheson Dr. Brick Breeland Actor Kaitlyn Black AnnaBeth Nass Actor Josh Cooke Joel Stephens Guest Star Antoinette Robertson Lynly Hayes Guest Star Peter Mackenzie Rev. Peter Mayfair Guest Star Steven M. Porter Frank Moth Guest Star Brandi Burkhardt Crickett Watts Guest Star Charlie Robinson Sergeant Jeffries Guest Star John Marshall Jones Wally Maynard Guest Star Reginald VelJohnson Dash DeWitt Guest Star Ross Philips Tom Long Guest Star Mallory Moye Wanda Guest Star Matt Lowe Meatball Guest Star John Eric Bentley Sheriff Bill Guest Star Karla Mosley Elodie Guest Star Armelia McQueen Shula Guest Star Carla Renata Susie Guest Star Bayne Gibby Shanetta Guest Star Lilan Bowden Collette Guest Star Elizabeth Hunter Maisie Guest Star Mandy Levin Mrs. Mayfair Guest Star Joe Massingill Cody Guest Star Leila Gerstein Executive Producer Josh Schwartz Executive Producer Stephanie Savage Executive Producer Len Goldstein Executive Producer Jason Ensler Executive Producer David Paymer Director Sarah Kucserka Writer Veronica West Writer