Jack Coleman Mr. Bennet, HRG Actor Greg Grunberg Matt Parkman Actor Robert Knepper Samuel Sullivan Actor Ali Larter Tracy Strauss, Niki Sanders, Jessica Actor James Kyson Ando Masahashi Actor Masi Oka Hiro Makamura Actor Hayden Panettiere Claire Bennett Actor Adrian Pasdar Nathan Petrelli Actor Zachary Quinto Sylar Actor Sendhil Ramamurthy Mohinder Suresh Actor Cristine Rose Angela Petrelli Actor Milo Ventimiglia Peter Petrelli Actor Lisa Lackey Guest Star Dawn Olivieri Guest Star Elisabeth Röhm Guest Star Kate Vernon Guest Star Deanne Bray Guest Star Todd Stashwick Guest Star Sasha Pieterse Guest Star