Mary McCormack Mary Shannon Actor Frederick Weller Marshall Mann Actor Nichole Hiltz Brandi Shannon Actor Todd Williams Bobby D Actor Lesley Ann Warren Jinx Shannon Actor Jane Adams Ruth Fraser , Ruth Ferguson Guest Star John Benjamin Hickey Donald Fraser , Donald Ferguson Guest Star James MacDonald Peter O'Dell Guest Star David Meunier Phil Guest Star Christopher Stanley Joe Guest Star Cristian de la Fuente Raphael Ramirez Guest Star Tom Schuch Father O'Brien Guest Star David Garver Pat Conner Guest Star Rio Alexander Dave Thundercloud Guest Star Debrianna Mansini Betty Thundercloud Guest Star John Showalter Director Jessica Butler Writer Brynn Malone Writer