Dave Navarro Host Chris Nunez Judge Oliver Peck Judge Tray "Big Daddy" Benham Contestant Clint Cummings Contestant Nick D'Angelo Contestant Jamie Davies Contestant Katherine "Tatu Baby" Flores Contestant La Ron "Ron" Givens Contestant Steven "Kay Kutta" Givens Contestant Thomas "TJ" Halvorsen Contestant Cee Jay Jones Contestant Mark Matthews Contestant Sarah Miller Contestant Sebastian Murphy Contestant Jesse Smith Contestant Little Mike Contestant Steve Tefft Contestant Lalo Yunda Contestant