Alan Davies Jonathan Creek Actor Sarah Alexander Polly Creek Actor John Bird Horace Greeley Actor Paula Wilcox Hazel Prosser Actor Warwick Davis Rev. Wendell Wilkie Actor Ken Bones Nathan Clore Actor Josie Lawrence Denise Actor Raquel Cassidy Sharon Actor James Bachman Rev Hugh Chater Actor Selina Griffiths Alison Chater Actor June Whitfield Heidi and Laurel Greeley Actor Emun Elliott Stephen Belkin Actor Michael Troughton Leonard Corbyn Actor David Sant Director Rosemary McGowan Producer Sandy Johnson Director David Renwick Executive Producer, Writer Pete Thornton Executive Producer