Jordan Peele Various Characters Creator, Actor, Executive Producer, Writer Keegan-Michael Key Various Characters Creator, Actor, Executive Producer, Writer Jordan Black Pegasus Fan Actor Rob Delaney White Guy in Negraph Commercial Actor Colton Dunn Eyewitness Actor, Writer Daniele Gaither Pegasus Protester Actor Dee Kevin Pegasus Witness Actor Peter Atencio Director Payman Benz Director Jay Martel Writer Ian Roberts Executive Producer, Writer Keith Raskin Producer Joel Zadak Producer Sean Conroy Writer Rebecca Drysdale Writer Alex Rubens Writer Charlie Sanders Writer