John Smith Slim Sherman Actor Robert Fuller Jess Harper Actor Robert Crawford Jr. Andy Sherman Actor Stuart Randall Mort Corey Actor Mary Murphy Lottie Guest Star Lori Nelson Grace Guest Star Gregory Walcott Shelly Stack Guest Star Frank Ferguson Scotty Guest Star Jan Merlin Jo Jo Guest Star Willard Waterman Bender Guest Star James Anderson Link Guest Star Rand Brooks Carr Guest Star Terry Frost Mr. Bender Guest Star Lesley Selander Director Arthur Browne Jr. Writer