Tim Roth Dr. Cal Lightman Actor Kelli Williams Dr. Gillian Foster Actor Monica Raymund Ria Torres Actor Brendan Hines Eli Loker Actor Mekhi Phifer FBI Agent Ben Reynolds Actor Hayley McFarland Emily Lightman Actor J. Michael Trautmann Mark Guest Star Katie Mitchell Renee Guest Star Kevin Rankin Kent Clark Guest Star Kristolyn Lloyd Cara Guest Star Lenny Citrano Public Defender Guest Star Luke Youngblood Kid Guest Star Maura Knowles Soccer Mom Guest Star Annabeth Gish Ilene Clark Guest Star Merle Dandridge D.A. Jill Ottinger Guest Star Jennifer Weston Nurse Guest Star Samuel Baum Executive Producer Brian Grazer Executive Producer Shawn Ryan Executive Producer Samantha Howard Corbin Writer Dailyn Rodriguez Writer Michael Offer Director