Tom Kapinos Creator Tom Ellis Lucifer Actor Lauren German Chloe Actor DB Woodside Amenadiel Actor Lesley-Ann Brandt Maze Actor Kevin Alejandro Dan Actor Scarlett Estevez Trixie Actor Rachael Harris Linda Martin Actor Tricia Helfer Charlotte Actor Aimee Garcia Ella Actor Tom Welling Marcus Pierce Actor Marco Sanchez Lt. Herrera Guest Star Erica Cerra Athena Guest Star Haig Sutherland Norm Guest Star Stephanie Bennett Muffy Guest Star Andy Nez Pete Guest Star Cate Cohen Joan Guest Star Chris McKenna Ben Rivers Guest Star Nathan Hope Director Neil Gaiman Writer Sam Kieth Writer