Jonathan Groff Holden Ford Actor Holt McCallany Bill Tench Actor Anna Torv Wendy Actor Hannah Gross Debbie Mitford Actor Cotter Smith Robert Shepard Actor Joe Tuttle Gregg Smith Guest Star Duke Lafoon Detective Chambers Guest Star Ryan Dinning Officer Winston Brassel Guest Star Adam William Zastrow Gene Devier Guest Star Marc Kudisch Roger Wade Guest Star Rhoda Griffis Esther Mayweather Guest Star Michael Park Peter Dean Guest Star George Sheffey John Boylen Guest Star Cameron Britton Ed Kemper Guest Star Meredith Jackson Nurse Guest Star David Fincher Executive Producer Joshua Donen Executive Producer Charlize Theron Executive Producer Ceán Chaffin Executive Producer