Callie Thorne Dani Santino Actor Scott Cohen Nico Careles Actor Marc Blucas Matthew Donnally Actor Mehcad Brooks Terrence King Actor Joe Theismann Guest Star Neil Hopkins Guest Star Peter MacNicol Guest Star Robbie Jones Guest Star Michaela McManus Guest Star Tom Nowicki Guest Star James Black Guest Star Elizabeth Kruger Executive Producer Craig Shapiro Executive Producer Kevin Dowling Executive Producer Jeffrey Lieber Executive Producer