Carly Pope Sam McPherson Actor Leslie Bibb Brooke McQueen Actor Tammy Lynn Michaels Nicole Julian Actor Kip Pardue Actor Christopher Gorham Harrison John Actor Tamara Mello Lily Esposito Actor Sara Rue Carmen Ferrara Actor Sydney Forest Self Delta Burke Guest Star Alley Mills Guest Star Peggy Lipton Guest Star Lisa Blount Guest Star Geoff Pierson Guest Star Michelle Krusiec Guest Star Tiffeny Milbrett Guest Star Tisha Venturini Guest Star Wentworth Miller Guest Star Erik Estrada Guest Star Leslie Grossman Mary Cherry Guest Star Ron Lester Michael Sugar Daddy Bernadino Guest Star Ryan Murphy Executive Producer, Writer Gina Matthews Executive Producer Greer Shephard Executive Producer Michael M. Robin Executive Producer, Director Jamie Babbit Director Lev Spiro Director Perry Lang Director Marc Buckland Director Elodie Keene Director Arvin Brown Director Craig Zisk Director David Petrarca Director Wendy MacLeod Writer Ari Posner Writer Edward Kitsis Writer Oliver Goldstick Writer Adam Horowitz Writer Eric Preven Writer