Alyssa Milano Host Isaac Mizrahi Judge Georgina Chapman Judge Zanna Roberts Rassi Actor Jeffrey Sebelia Contestant Mychael Knight Contestant Korto Momolu Contestant Irina Shabayeva Contestant Seth Aaron Henderson Contestant Andy South Contestant Viktor Luna Contestant Melissa Fleis Contestant Christopher Palu Contestant Elena Slivnyak Contestant Daniel Esquivel Contestant Anthony Ryan Auld Guest Star Gabourey Sidibe Guest Star Francisco Costa Guest Star Elisabeth Moss Guest Star Michelle Smith Guest Star