Alan Tudyk Harry Vanderspeigle Actor Sara Tomko Asta Twelvetrees Actor Corey Reynolds Sheriff Mike Thompson Actor Alice Wetterlund D'Arcy Bloom Actor Levi Fiehler Ben Hawthorne Actor Elizabeth Bowen Deputy Liv Baker Actor Meredith Garretson Kate Hawthorne Actor Ben Cotton Guest Elvy Guest Chris Sheridan Executive Producer, Writer Mike Richardson Executive Producer Keith Goldberg Executive Producer Justin Falvey Executive Producer Darryl Frank Executive Producer David Dobkin Executive Producer Robert Duncan McNeill Executive Producer, Director