Melissa Joan Hart Sabrina Spellman Actor Caroline Rhea Hilda Spellman Actor Beth Broderick Zelda Spellman Actor Nate Richert Harvey Kinkle Actor Jenna Leigh Green Libby Chessler Actor Lindsay Sloane Valerie Birkhead Actor Nick Bakay Salem Saberhagen Voice Alimi Ballard Quizmaster Albert Actor Martin Mull Actor Buddy Hackett Guest Star Tim Maculan Guest Star Yolanda Snowball Guest Star Phillip Bergeron Guest Star Paula Hart Executive Producer Nell Scovell Executive Producer, Writer Peter Baldwin Director Charlie Tercek Writer