Janet Montgomery Mary Sibley Actor Shane West John Alden Actor Seth Gabel Cotton Mather Actor Ashley Madekwe Tituba Actor Tamzin Merchant Anne Hale Actor Elise Eberle Mercy Lewis Actor Joe Doyle Baron Sebastian Marburg Actor Oliver Bell Actor Iddo Goldberg Isaac Walton Actor Lucy Lawless Countess Marburg Actor Stuart Townsend Samuel Wainwright Actor Jeremy Crutchley Hathorne Guest Star Samantha Hanratty Dollie Trask Guest Star Hank Harris Corwin Guest Star Michael Mulheren George Sibley Guest Star Thomas Francis Murphy Reverend Lewis Guest Star Jim Blumetti Farmer Guest Star David Kallaway Militia Man Guest Star Ian Sinclair Nathaniel Guest Star Skyler Davenport Acolyte Guest Star Marcus Graves Egyptian Executioner Guest Star Gregory Nye Selectman Guest Star Jeremy Summers Townsfolk Guest Star Stan Taylor Townsperson Guest Star Adam Simon Executive Producer Brannon Braga Executive Producer Josh S. Barry Executive Producer Jeff Kwatinetz Executive Producer