Cinco Paul Creator Ken Daurio Creator Cecily Strong Melissa Gimble Actor Keegan-Michael Key Josh Skinner Actor Fred Armisen Reverend Layton Actor Kristin Chenoweth Mildred Layton Actor Alan Cumming Mayor Menlove Actor Aaron Tveit Danny Bailey Actor Dove Cameron Betsy Actor Ariana DeBose Emma Tate Actor Jaime Camil Doc Lopez Actor Jane Krakowski The Countess Actor Ann Harada Florence Menlove Actor Lorne Michaels Executive Producer Andrew Singer Executive Producer Barry Sonnenfeld Executive Producer