Marcia Gay Harden Margaret Wright Actor Skylar Astin Todd Actor Madeline Wise Allison Actor Tristen Winger Lyle Actor Inga Schlingmann Susan Actor Rosa Arredondo Francey Actor Clayton James Chuck Grant Guest Star Thomas Cadrot Chet Guest Star Lydia Campbell Kate Guest Star Matthew Sears Elliot Guest Star Erik Knudsen Brian McAtee Guest Star Andrew J. Hampton Derek Guest Star Paul McGillion Trevor Rapp Guest Star Julie Howgate Erica Guest Star Camille Mitchell Desiree Guest Star Frank Crudele Jerry Guest Star Matt Afonso Grady Tibbels Guest Star Greg Kean Ray McAtee Guest Star Nikki Chohan Police Officer #1 Guest Star Matthew Mandzij Police Officer #2 Guest Star Sarah Hayward Mrs. Garrison Guest Star Shawn Richard Will Guest Star Jeremy Gimenez Johnny McAtee Guest Star Cruze McKinnon Danny McAtee Guest Star Bobby L. Dupree Judge Dupree Guest Star Karen Khunkhun Reporter Guest Star Scott Prendergast Executive Producer Elizabeth Kruger Executive Producer Elizabeth Klaviter Executive Producer Phil McGraw Executive Producer Jay McGraw Executive Producer Julia Eisenman Executive Producer Amy York Rubin Executive Producer Lisa Parsons Writer Robert Duncan McNeill Director