Joey Lawrence Host Charissa Thompson Host Greg Louganis Judge David Boudia Judge Louie Anderson Contestant Drake Bell Contestant Chuy Bravo Contestant Nicole Eggert Contestant Keshia Knight Pulliam Contestant Ndamukong Suh Contestant Katherine Webb Contestant Kendra Wilkinson Contestant Kareem Abdul-Jabaar Contestant Rory Bushfield Contestant J.D. Roth Executive Producer Todd Nelson Executive Producer Brant Pinvidic Executive Producer Josh Greenberg Executive Producer