Jeremy Sisto George Altman Actor Jane Levy Tessa Altman Actor Cheryl Hines Dallas Royce Actor Alan Tudyk Noah Werner Actor Carly Chaikin Dalia Royce Actor Ana Gasteyer Sheila Shay Actor Allie Grant Lisa Shay Actor Rex Lee Mr. Wolfe Actor Parker Young Guest Star Maestro Harrell Guest Star Chris Parnell Guest Star Gillian Vigman Guest Star Kurt Ela Guest Star Maria Russell Guest Star Alicia Silverstone Guest Star Emily Kapnek Executive Producer Andrew Guest Writer Peter Lauer Writer