Stephen Amell Ted Black Actor Lex Scott Davis Erica Rollins Actor Josh McDermitt Stuart Lane Actor Bryan Greenberg Rick Dodson Actor Alice Lee Leah Power Guest Star Rachelle Goulding Samantha Railsback Guest Star Troy Winbush Kevin Dillon Guest Star Azita Ghanizada Rosalyn Noori Guest Star Kevin Weisman Lester Thompson Guest Star Brian Baumgartner Brian Baumgartner Guest Star Patton Oswalt Patton Oswalt Guest Star Carson A. Egan Eddie Black Guest Star Matt Letscher Ted's Father Guest Star Kristen Hager Valerie Guest Star Dan Sanders-Joyce Jimmy Patriale Guest Star Frankie Kevich Young Lawyer Guest Star Nik Shriner Mail Cart Guy Guest Star Aaron Korsh Executive Producer David Bartis Executive Producer Doug Liman Executive Producer Gene Klein Executive Producer Anton Cropper Executive Producer Genevieve Sparling Executive Producer, Writer Rick Muirragui Executive Producer Jon Cowan Executive Producer Christopher Misiano Director