Mary-Ellis Bunim Creator T.J. Lavin Host Nehemiah Clark Self Maria Menounos Host Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio Self Tori Deal Self Michele Fitzgerald Self Rachel Robinson Contestant Josh Martinez Self Derek Chavez Self Evelyn Smith Contestant Amanda Garcia Contestant Ryan Kehoe Contestant Jenny West Self Rachel Robinson Self Cara Maria Sorbello Self Kyland Young Contestant Jonna Mannion Contestant Laurel Stucky Self Cory Wharton Self Jordan Wiseley Self Fred Birckhead Executive Producer Kevin Lee Executive Producer