Alexandra Chando Emma Becker, Sutton Mercer Actor Andy Buckley Ted Mercer Actor Allie Gonino Laurel Mercer Actor Alice Greczyn Madeline "Mads" Rybak Actor Sharon Pierre-Louis Nisha Randall Actor Kirsten Zien Charlotte "Char" Chamberlin Actor Blair Redford Ethan Whitehorse Actor Helen Slater Kristin Mercer Actor Adrian Pasdar Alec Rybak Actor Christian Alexander Thayer Rybak Actor Randy Wayne Justin Miller Actor Dora Madison Lexi Samuel Guest Star Travis Caldwell Kelvin Timmons Guest Star Ben Elliott Derek Rogers Guest Star Jennifer Griffin Dr. Hughes Guest Star Farah White Danni Samuels Guest Star Sydney Barrosse Phyllis Chamberlin Guest Star John Scott Horton Troy Guest Star Chad Halbrook Terry Guest Star Debrianna Mansini Clarice Guest Star Adam Madrigal Hero Guest Star Holland Sanders Guest Star Vanessa Amaya Popular Girl, Party Guest Guest Star David C. Bates II Student Guest Star Isabel Elena Arroyo High School Student Guest Star Mike Reilly Golfer, Country Club Patron Guest Star Charles Pratt Jr. Executive Producer Leslie Morgenstein Executive Producer Gina Girolamo Executive Producer Joe Lazarov Director R. Lee Fleming Jr. Writer