Mary-Ellis Bunim Creator Jonathan Murray Creator Maria Menounos Host Nate Burleson Host Ace Amerson Contestant Alton Williams Contestant Aneesa Ferreira Contestant Beth Stolarczyk Contestant Darrell Taylor Contestant Derrick Kosinski Contestant Eric "Big Easy" Banks Contestant Jemmye Carroll Contestant Jisela Delgado Contestant Jonna Mannion Contestant Katie Cooley Contestant KellyAnne Judd Contestant Kendal Sheppard Contestant Laterrian Wallace Contestant Mark Long Contestant, Executive Producer Nehemiah Clark Contestant Ruthie Alcaide Contestant Syrus Yarbrough Contestant Teck Holmes Contestant Trishelle Cannatella Contestant Yes Duffy Contestant Julie Pizzi Executive Producer Ryan Smith Executive Producer Fred Birckhead Executive Producer Dan Caster Executive Producer Leanne Mucci Executive Producer Skye Topic Co-Executive Producer Micah Kehoe-Thompson Co-Executive Producer Alex Rosenbloom Co-Executive Producer Eric Spagnoletti Co-Executive Producer Rob Whitaker Co-Executive Producer Kristin Bihr Co-Executive Producer Craig Alsop Supervising Producer Cami Kershek Supervising Producer Jared March Supervising Producer