Mary-Ellis Bunim Creator T.J. Lavin Host Wes Bergmann Contestant Michaela Bradshaw Contestant Paulie Calafiore Contestant Cassidy Clark Contestant Luis Colon Contestant Tyler Crispen Contestant Tori Deal Contestant Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio Contestant Michele Fitzgerald Contestant Dusty Harris Contestant Chanelle Howell Contestant Ameerah Jones Contestant Alyssa Lopez Contestant Josh Martinez Contestant Tiffany Mitchell Contestant Sebastian Noel Contestant Faysal Shafaat Contestant Alyssa Snider Contestant Monte Taylor Contestant Chris Underwood Contestant Cory Wharton Contestant Desi Williams Contestant Jonna Mannion Contestant Amanda Garcia Contestant Julie Pizzi Executive Producer Justin Booth Executive Producer