Michael Piller Creator, Executive Producer, Writer Shawn Piller Creator, Producer Anthony Michael Hall Johnny Smith Actor Nicole de Boer Sarah Bracknell Bannerman Actor Chris Bruno Sheriff Walt Bannerman Actor John L. Adams Bruce Lewis Actor David Ogden Stiers Rev. Gene Purdy Actor Jennifer Finnigan Alex Sinclair Guest Star Craig March Gunman , Frank Monroe Guest Star Jessica Amlee Alex at age 9 Guest Star Lloyd Segan Executive Producer Karl Schaefer Executive Producer, Writer Tommy Thompson Executive Producer Mike Rohl Director