Jim Gaffigan Jim Actor, Executive Producer Ashley Williams Jeannie Actor Adam Goldberg Dave Actor Michael Ian Black Daniel Actor Tongai Arnold Chirisa Father Nicholas Actor Fred Armisen Dr. Weiss Guest Star Vanessa Aspillaga Blanca Guest Star Mike Britt Cop Guest Star Jimmy Failla Comedy Club MC Guest Star Marcella Lowery Receptionist Guest Star Lucian Middleton James Guest Star Caitlin Moeller Elizabeth, Elizabeth Guest Star, Actor Yamaneika Saunders Woman in Park Guest Star Maisie Sexton Mary Guest Star Jeff Lowell Executive Producer Jeannie Gaffigan Executive Producer Alex Murray Executive Producer Sandy Wernick Executive Producer Michael Wimer Executive Producer