Mark Duplass Pete Actor Steve Rannazzisi Kevin Actor Nick Kroll Ruxin Actor Paul Scheer Andre Actor Jon Lajoie Taco Actor Katie Aselton Jenny Actor Nadine Velazquez Sofia Guest Star Adam Karchmer Baby Geoffrey Guest Star Leonard Earl Howze Sky Cap Guest Star Tava Smiley Tricia Valence Guest Star Matt Iseman Airport Police Officer Guest Star Jeff Schaffer Executive Producer Jackie Marcus Schaffer Executive Producer