Episode 1
Aired Sep 9, 1961
Full Payment
When Jack Barron's gang of outlaws heads to Lincoln to take revenge upon Billy, Garret deputizes the Kid to help protect the town.
Details
Episode 2
Aired Sep 19, 1961
The Liberty Belle
Pat's former girlfriend, Elena, returns to Lincoln to seek his help when she is targeted by her other ex-lover, the outlaw Joe Durango.
Details
Episode 3
Aired Sep 23, 1961
Where Is Sylvia?
A con artist pretending to be the wife of a man who lost his money to Garrett in a poker game convinces the lawman to return his winnings.
Details
Episode 4
Aired Sep 30, 1961
The Female Artillery
After being wounded by marauding Apaches, Billy must come to the defense of a group of women and children hiding in an abandoned fort.
Details
Episode 5
Aired Oct 7, 1961
Shadow of the Past
Garrett believes the father of Billy's new girlfriend is the man who foiled his escape from a Confederate prison camp during the Civil War.
Details
Episode 6
Aired Oct 14, 1961
An Item for Auction
A man tries to marry off his teenage daughter, Mary Susan, to whomever will pay the most money.
Details
Episode 7
Aired Oct 21, 1961
The Judas Palm
After Garrett releases one of Billy's family friends from custody, the man commits a robbery and murder and frames Billy for the crimes.
Details
Episode 8
Aired Oct 28, 1961
The Woman
When Garrett kills a pioneer for stealing a horse, the pioneer's group leader declares that Garrett must die unless the thief's widow shows him mercy.
Details
Episode 9
Aired Nov 4, 1961
Trial by Hanging
When Billy becomes caught up in a cattle-rustling operation, his life is threatened by a lynch mob made up of frustrated ranchers.
Details
Episode 10
Aired Nov 11, 1961
The Leopard's Spots
Billy gives up his gun to impress a beautiful girl, motivating Bart Conway to take over Tundall's ranch and attempt to murder the defenseless Kid.
Details
Episode 11
Aired Nov 18, 1961
Petticoat Crusade
Suffragette Amy Dodds gets herself arrested to gain publicity by claiming that Sheriff Garrett mistreated her while she was in custody.
Details
Episode 12
Aired Nov 25, 1961
Time of Foreshadowing
Billy repays an old debt to his friend Skip Farrell by helping him escape from a posse.
Details
Episode 13
Aired Dec 2, 1961
Fool's Play
On his first assignment as a stagecoach guard, Billy must track down a pair of outlaws who gun down the coach's driver and steal a strongbox.
Details
Episode 14
Aired Dec 9, 1961
The Legend of Billy
Billy pretends to be a notorious criminal for a newspaper story, which prompts the New Mexican government to investigate Sheriff Garrett.
Details
Episode 15
Aired Dec 16, 1961
A Tombstone for Billy
Garrett suspects Billy of stealing a marble tombstone from a stone cutter's shop, but can't find any evidence to confirm his theory.
Details
Episode 16
Aired Dec 23, 1961
Sidekick
After Billy rescues a Mexican boy from an abusive wagon driver, he learns of a town stuck under the thumb of a crooked businessman.
Details
Episode 17
Aired Dec 30, 1961
Apache Daughter
Garrett helps return a kidnapped woman to her father after nine years of living with the Apaches, but the reunion is complicated by the daughter's desire to live with her warrior husband, Talano.
Details
Episode 18
Aired Jan 6, 1962
Substitute Sheriff
Threatened with eviction, May and June McBean trick Garrett into leaving Lincoln so their father can pose as sheriff and prevent the seizure of their ranch.
Details
Episode 19
Aired Jan 13, 1962
The Girl from Paradise
After Billy and Anne Drake are framed for murder by Sheriff Bob Tollinger, they must escape from his posse while chained together.
Details
Episode 20
Aired Jan 20, 1962
St. Louis Woman
An engaged widow finds Garrett to be a more desirable husband than her fiance.
Details
Episode 21
Aired Jan 27, 1962
The Hunt
A wealthy man recruits Billy to be his guide on an expedition to hunt mountain lions, but his true target turns out to be the Kid himself.
Details
Episode 22
Aired Feb 3, 1962
The Impatient Brides
When an Apache uprising traps a large number of people in Lincoln, Garrett opens his jail cells to shelter stagecoach passengers who turn out to be mail-order brides.
Details
Episode 23
Aired Feb 10, 1962
Rio Doloroso
Garrett and a prisoner seek shelter in an impoverished pueblo during a storm, where the residents offer hospitality in the hopes of being well-compensated.
Details
Episode 24
Aired Feb 17, 1962
A Day to Kill
Billy receives treatment for a concussion he sustained from falling off a horse, but his medication causes him to believe the entire town wants him dead.
Details
Episode 25
Aired Feb 24, 1962
Property of the Crown
When a Mexican woman presents a Spanish document granting her family ownership of half the land in Lincoln County, Garrett must investigate the legitimacy of her claim.
Details
Episode 26
Aired Mar 3, 1962
Night of the Hawk
Garrett and Billy question a martinet officer's ability to negotiate the surrender of a band of renegade Apaches.
Details
Episode 27
Aired Mar 10, 1962
Three for All
When Garrett arrests the Killgor brothers, their mother comes to their rescue by locking the sheriff in a jail cell and taking her family on a crime spree.
Details
Episode 28
Aired Mar 17, 1962
Quarantine
Garrett takes a wounded bank robber to the doctor, only to end up in quarantine when a man exhibiting signs of bubonic plague stumbles through the door.
Details
Episode 29
Aired Mar 24, 1962
The Four Queens
A visiting showman presents Garrett with evidence that one of his performers plans to kill Billy.
Details
Episode 30
Aired Mar 31, 1962
The Long Way Home
Billy becomes the prime suspect in the murder of a federal marshal who was investigating a freight train for contraband.
Details
Episode 31
Aired Apr 7, 1962
A Time to Run
A timid man asks Garrett to take him into custody for robbing a crooked St. Louis politician. After corroborating his story, the sheriff must defend the man against a hired assassin.
Details
Episode 32
Aired Apr 14, 1962
Trial by Fury
A vengeful judge lures Billy and two others to a remote village where he presides over a retrial of past cases in which the three had been found innocent.
Details
Episode 33
Aired Apr 21, 1962
The Frame
A terminally ill man, jealous of his wife's past relationship with Garrett, plots to commit suicide and frame his wife for his murder.
Details
Episode 34
Aired Apr 28, 1962
The Runaway Groom
Sally Tugwell arrives in Lincoln with her brothers and an infant, claiming that Billy is her husband, but Billy insists he doesn't know her.
Details
Episode 35
Aired May 5, 1962
The Black Robe
Gov. Lew Wallace orders Garrett to investigate the suspected delivery of firearms to the Apaches by a French agent, leading to the possibility that a European power is conspiring to occupy Mexico.
Details
Episode 36
Aired May 12, 1962
The Woman in Black
Don Diego insists that Garrett arrest his ex-fiancée Rosa for placing a curse on his family after his son dies in a horseback accident.
Details
Episode 37
Aired May 19, 1962
Doctor on Horseback
A new doctor's poor bedside manner earns him an unfavorable reputation until a crisis with a suicidal pregnant woman offers him a chance at redemption.
Details
Episode 38
Aired May 26, 1962
Phoebe
Billy must find a runaway girl when the girl's father believes that Billy murdered her.
Details