Lily Rabe Claire Bennigan Actor Barry Sloane Wes Lawrence Actor Milo Ventimiglia John Doe Actor Derek Webster Jessup Rollins Actor Kristen Connolly Lena Larence Actor Kylie Rogers Minx Lawrence Actor Kyle Breitkopf Henry Bennigan Actor Catalina Denis Guest Star David Andrews Guest Star Martin Cummins Guest Star Darien Provost Guest Star Tom Butler Guest Star Jeremy Guilbaut Guest Star Sarah Edmondson Guest Star Alex Zahara Guest Star Wesley Salter Guest Star Austin Dunn Guest Star Murat Kocaoglu Guest Star Howie Lai Guest Star Marc Senior Guest Star Jason Simpson Guest Star Steven Spielberg Executive Producer Justin Falvey Executive Producer Darryl Frank Executive Producer Dawn Parouse Executive Producer Holly Harold Writer Dean Widenmann Writer