Justin Hartley Colter Shaw Actor, Executive Producer Fiona Rene Reenie Actor Robin Weigert Teddi Actor Abby McEnany Velma Actor Eric Graise Bobby Actor Melissa Roxburgh Dr. Dory Shaw Guest Star Anja Savcic Kira Stine Guest Star Marley Shelton Erika Guest Star Sofia Pernas Billie Matalon Guest Star Steve Dhillon Jonathan Tyner Guest Star Martin Roach Clay Porter Guest Star Jensen Ackles Russell Guest Star Cassandra Sawtell Lisa Jefferson Guest Star Dana L. Wilson Deborah Porter Guest Star Richard Harmon Matt Winslow Guest Star Peter Oldring Hugh Lazlo Guest Star Kudakwashe Rutendo Stephanie Porter Guest Star Michelle Morgan Tina Lazlo Guest Star Gia Sandhu Beth Trainor Guest Star Ken Olin Executive Producer, Director Ben H. Winters Executive Producer, Writer Jeffrey Deaver Executive Producer Travis Donnelly Writer Elwood Reid Writer, Executive Producer Sharon Lee Watson Writer Tegan Shohet Writer Clara Aranovich Director Steve Harper Writer David Radcliff Writer Jai Franklin Sarki Writer Larry Teng Director Graham Thiel Writer Douglas Aarniokoski Director Gonzalo Amat Director Aprill Winney Director