Justin Hartley Colter Shaw Actor, Executive Producer Fiona Rene Reenie Actor Chris Lee Randy Actor Erica Durance Laura Guest Star Cassady McClincy Zhang Mel Actor Jensen Ackles Russell Shaw Guest Star Italia Ricci MC Actor Sofia Pernas Billie Guest Star Derek Richardson Dundee Guest Star Benito Martinez Dale Buchanan Actor Chris Jericho Virgil Guest Star Madalyn Horcher Noelle Buchanan Actor Tobias Jelinek Milo Simmons Actor Michael Aaron Milligan Andy Fleming Actor Tyler Johnston Graham Benning Actor James Roney Vince Unger Actor Alana Hawley Purvis Officer Shonda Crosby Actor Clay St. Thomas Gene Benning Actor Petar Gatsby Jenks Actor Tyler Roy Roberts Delivery Driver Actor Ken Olin Executive Producer, Director Ben H. Winters Executive Producer Jeffrey Deaver Executive Producer Elwood Reid Executive Producer, Writer Sharon Lee Watson Writer Ryan O'Nan Writer Alex Katsnelson Writer Alex Katnelson Writer Travis Donnelly Writer Annakate Chappell Writer Jai Franklin Sarki Writer Jeff T. Thomas Director Amanda Mortlock Writer Brian McCauley Johnson Writer Dominique Holmes Writer Joel Novoa Director Aprill Winney Director