Jamie Bell Abraham Woodhull Actor Seth Numrich Ben Tallmadge Actor Daniel Henshall Caleb Brewster Actor Heather Lind Anna Strong Actor Meegan Warner Mary Woodhull Actor Samuel Roukin Lt. John Simcoe Actor Kevin R. McNally Judge Richard Woodhull Actor Ksenia Solo Peggy Shippen Actor Ian Kahn Gen. George Washington Actor Owain Yeoman Benedict Arnold Actor Nick Westrate Robert Townsend Actor Aldis Hodge Jordan Guest Star John Carroll Lynch James Rivington Guest Star Kelly AuCoin Hercules Mulligan Guest Star Tina Benko Mrs. Barnes Guest Star Christian Clemenson Martin De Young Guest Star Jonathan Coyne Col. Jonathan Cooke Guest Star Amy Gumenick Philomena Cheer Guest Star Idara Victor Abigail Guest Star Karen Abercrombie Aberdeen Guest Star Sofiya Akilova Becky Franks Guest Star Jeff Campanella Kilroy Guest Star James Donadio Maj. Dundas Guest Star Marcus Crawford Guy Ensign Harris Guest Star Sean Haggerty Col. Alexander Hamilton, Frontiersman, Militia Guest Star, Guest Star Mark Halpern Appleton Guest Star Andrew Kaempfer Bouncer Guest Star Brian Lafontaine Dr. Josiah Mabbs Guest Star Laura Meakin Hesther Carney Guest Star Sasha Morfaw Zipporah Guest Star Joshua Price Freddy Guest Star Gabriel Rush Townie Guest Star Stephen Shelton Horseman, Frink Guest Star Ashley Smith Capt. Wakefield Guest Star Mark Allan Stewart Teddy Beddows Guest Star William Vaughan Sailor Guest Star Kody Kight Redcoat Guest Star Elaina Adrianna Rivington Escort Guest Star Aaron Angus Dragoon Guest Star Greg Black British Officer Guest Star Justyn Christofel NY Gentleman, Loyalist Guest Star Alex Elfner Female Actor Friend Guest Star Rick Ford Royal British Officer Guest Star Raymond H. Johnson New York Tory Gentleman Guest Star Seth Kozak Redcoat Officer Guest Star Dakota James Alden Lane Redcoat Guest Star Christopher Leber Male Actor Friend Guest Star George Ludden Townsperson Guest Star Dwight Tolar British Officer Guest Star Craig Silverstein Executive Producer, Director, Writer Barry Josephson Executive Producer Michael Taylor Co-Executive Producer