Poppy Montgomery Carrie Wells Actor Dylan Walsh Det. Al Burns Actor Michael Gaston Det. Mike Costello Actor Kevin Rankin Det. Roe Saunders Actor Daya Vaidya Det. Nina Inara Actor Deanna Dunagan Alice Guest Star George Aloi Priest Guest Star Peter Benson Father Anselm Guest Star Derek Cecil Adam Coyer, Dean of Students Guest Star Carl Ducena NYPD Officer Guest Star Anna Friedman Katie Monaghan Guest Star Jack Gwaltney Sean O'Malley Guest Star Marilu Henner Aunt Evie Guest Star Anna Rose Hopkins Shannon Spicer Guest Star Pila Manivong Taxi Driver Guest Star Drew McVety Daniel Monaghan Guest Star Jamil Mena Rubin Lobato Guest Star Kellie Overbey Erin O'Malley Guest Star Kevin Rogers Jared Rainer Guest Star Aaron Sauter Gregory Smit Guest Star Tom Stratford Detective Guest Star Joe Urban The Big Money Man Guest Star Anne Yeomans Hannah Guest Star Mark Zeisler Attorney Guest Star Ed Redlich Executive Producer John Bellucci Executive Producer Sarah Timberman Executive Producer Carl Beverly Executive Producer Michael Foley Writer Paul Holahan Director