Amanda Bynes Holly Tyler Actor Jennie Garth Valerie Tyler Actor Simon Rex Jeff Actor Wesley Jonathan Gary Thorpe Actor Reid Scott Hunter Guest Star Samantha Esteban sasha Guest Star Keith Diamond Gene Guest Star Michael McMillian Henry Gibson Guest Star Nicholas DiNardo Scott Guest Star Cacey Riggan Girl in Line Guest Star Wil Calhoun Executive Producer Dan Schneider Executive Producer Brian Robbins Executive Producer Michael Tollin Executive Producer Joe Davola Executive Producer Shelley Jensen Director Stacy Traub Writer