Matt Bomer Neal Caffrey Actor Tim DeKay Peter Burke Actor Tiffani Thiessen Elizabeth Burke Actor Willie Garson Mozzie Actor Marsha Thomason Diana Barrigan Actor Sharif Atkins Clinton Jones Actor Jeremy Davidson Jack Franklin Guest Star Max Martini John Deckard Guest Star Joe Morton Kyle Bancroft Guest Star Shirley Rumierk Rebecca Vidal Guest Star Todd Cerveris Dan Guest Star Robyn Payne U.S. Marshal Guest Star Nicholas Dullea Salesmen Guest Star Robert Cuccioli Stan Volker Guest Star Jeff Eastin Executive Producer