Penn Badgley Joe Goldberg, Jonathan Moore Actor Tati Gabrielle Marienne Actor Charlotte Ritchie Kate Actor Lukas Gage Adam Actor Tilly Keeper Phoebe Actor Amy-Leigh Hickman Nadia Actor Ed Speleers Rhys Actor Victoria Pedretti Actor Elizabeth Lail Actor Madeline Brewer Actor Shay Mitchell Actor Jenna Ortega Actor James Scully Actor Ambyr Childers Actor Carmela Zumbado Actor Saffron Burrows Actor Dylan Arnold Actor Shalita Grant Actor Travis Van Winkle Actor Scott Speedman Actor John Stamos Actor Luca Padovan Actor Zach Cherry Actor Griffin Matthews Actor Anna Camp Actor Greg Berlanti Executive Producer Sera Gamble Executive Producer Sarah Schechter Executive Producer Leslie Morgenstein Executive Producer Gina Girolamo Executive Producer Marcos Siega Executive Producer