Sutton Foster Liza Miller Actor Hilary Duff Kelsey Peters Actor Debi Mazar Maggie Actor Miriam Shor Diana Trout Actor Nico Tortorella Josh Actor Peter Hermann Charles Actor Molly Bernard Lauren Heller Actor Charles Michael Davis Zane Anders Actor Farah Alvin Melissa Guest Star Varín Ayala Indie Moderator Guest Star Holly Chou Beth Guest Star Joanna Glushak Moderator Guest Star Ana Isabelle Ana Guest Star Randi Kaplan Fern Guest Star Marc Lamont Hill Himself Guest Star Jason Ralph Jake Devereux Guest Star Michael Silverblatt Himself Guest Star Jennifer Westfeldt Pauline Guest Star Meghan Roberts Girl 2 Guest Star Darren Star Executive Producer, Director