Greg Berlanti Director Katherine Heigl Holly Berenson Actor, Executive Producer Josh Duhamel Eric Messer Actor Josh Lucas Sam Actor Christina Hendricks Alison Novak Actor Hayes MacArthur Peter Novak Actor Sarah Burns Janine Groff Actor Jessica St. Clair Beth Actor Alexis Clagett Sophie Actor Brynn Clagett Sophie Actor Brooke Clagett Sophie Actor Brooke Liddell Older Sophie Actor Kiley Liddell Older Sophie Actor Britt Flatmo Amy Actor Rob Huebel Ted Actor Melissa McCarthy Deedee Actor DeRay Davis Lonnie Actor Kumail Nanjiani Simon Actor Andrew Daly Scott Actor Bill Brochtrup Gary Actor Will Sasso Josh Actor Ian Deitchman Screenwriter Kristin Rusk Robinson Screenwriter Barry Josephson Producer Paul Brooks Producer Denise Di Novi Executive Producer Scott Niemeyer Executive Producer Norm Waitt Executive Producer Nancy Heigl Executive Producer Bruce Berman Executive Producer Andrew Dunn Cinematographer Maher Ahmad Production Design Jim Page Film Editing Blake Neely Original Music Debra McGuire Costume Design John Papsidera Casting Austin Gorg Art Director Cindy Carr Set Decoration