Stuart Gilmore Director Joel McCrea The Virginian Actor Brian Donlevy Trampas Actor Sonny Tufts Steve Andrews Actor Barbara Britton Molly Wood Actor Fay Bainter Mrs. Taylor Actor Henry O'Neill Mr. Taylor Actor William Frawley Honey Wiggen Actor Bill Edwards Sam Bennett Actor Minor Watson Judge Henry Actor Tom Tully Nebraska Actor Vince Barnett Baldy Actor Martin Garralaga Spanish Ed Actor Paul Guilfoyle Shorty Actor Marc Lawrence Pete Actor James Burke Andy Jones Actor Al Bridge Sheriff Actor Nana Bryant Mrs. Wood Actor Paul Jones Producer