Terence M. O'Keefe Director, Writer Tracey Gold Sue Bentley Actor Michael Sutton Jimmy Scrico Actor Robert Culp Fr. Patrick Actor Timothy Busfield Fr. Donnelly Actor James Quattrochi Vinny Actor Will Thayer Chuck Actor Matt Koruba Tony Actor Justin Berfield Flip Actor Ernie Lively Sheriff Actor Sonny Marinelli Nick Actor James Luisi Vincent Argento Actor Beth Tegarden Rosa Actor Michael Sabatino Agent Ross Actor Matt McKenzie Agent Baker Actor Marcia Rodd Mama Scrico Actor Pat Asanti Maxie Actor Anthony Albano Joey Actor Peter Liapis Ed Actor Gary Kohn Junkie Actor Ron Robbins Corrupt Cop Actor Christopher Kriesa Hardware Store Clerk Actor Pierre David Producer Larry Gershman Producer Noel A. Zanitsch Producer Mark Evan Schwartz Writer