Richard Benjamin Oliver Fry Director, Actor Patricia Heaton Paula McFadden Actor Jeff Daniels Elliot Garfield Actor Hallie Kate Eisenberg Lucy McFadden Actor Lynda Boyd Donna Douglas Actor Alan Cumming Mark Actor Sharon Wilkins Mrs. Crosby Actor Zak Santiago Dance Class Instructor Actor Marco Soriano Ronnie Burns Actor Woody Jeffreys Eddie, Ronnie's Assitant Actor Panos Grames Pianist Actor Jessica Van der Veen Stage Manager Actor Emily Holmes Rhonda Actor John Shaw First Gentleman Actor Jack O'Connell Salesman Actor Dominic Colón Mugger Actor Wass Stevens Mugger Actor Joe D'Onofrio Mugger Actor Ron Halder Lovell Actor John B. Lowe Man in Audience Actor Katey Wright Duchess Actor Ross Benjamin Catesby Actor William Samples Critic in Audience Actor Kurt Max Runte Richard III Troupe Actor Marcus Hondro Richard III Troupe Actor Kwesi Ameyaw Richard III Troupe Actor Marie Stillin Mark's Mother Actor Warren Takeuchi Auto Executive Actor Kevan Ohtsji Auto Executive Actor Telly Kousakis Young Man Outside Club Actor Neil Simon Screenwriter Timothy Marx Producer Danny Nowak Cinematographer David Wechsler First Assistant Director Murphy Occhino Second Assistant Director Adam T. Weisinger Second Assistant Director