Eric Close Shane Director, Actor Kristin Chenoweth Katherine Clark Actor, Executive Producer Scott Wolf Greg Scanton Actor Kevin Quinn Danny Scanton Actor Keith D. Robinson Brian Actor Jennifer Aspen Julie Actor, Executive Producer Maria Howell Carol Actor Isabella Frommelt Nora Actor Lacey Caroline Mariah Actor Keyon Shammare Pickett Jr. Scott Actor Eva Albright Emily Actor Stephen Starkweather Pete Actor Shante DeLoach Gwen Actor Johanna Jowett Mariah's Mom Actor Scarlett Blum Emma Actor Nicole Baxter Screenwriter David O'Donnell Executive Producer Dustin Rikert Producer Shawn Maurer Cinematographer Kat Spiess Film Editing Michael Baiardi Original Music Tom Lisowski Production Design Barbee S. Livingston Set Decoration Mitzi Corrigan Casting