Paul Ziller Director Brooke D'Orsay Cassie Actor Kristoffer Polaha Jake Actor Max Archibald Brandon Actor Chad Willett Craig Actor Nathan Lynn Ben Actor Greg Rogers Mayor Givens Actor Cheyenne Rouleau Leah Actor Jovanna Burke Allison Dorsey Actor Camille Mitchell Marilyn Actor Robert Leaf Ray Muller Actor Cheryl Swan Nancy Actor Lauren K. Robek Denise Actor Laura Yenga Millie Actor Anthony Demare Thomas Actor Eric Pollins Andy Fitzgerald Actor Neetu Garcha TV Interviewer Actor Todd Matthews Robert Actor Nevin Burkholder Hank Actor David Santana Nathan Actor Mark Hefti Screenwriter Julie Sherman Wolfe Screenwriter Alexandre Coscas Executive Producer Antonio Cupo Executive Producer Michael R. Goldstein Executive Producer Ben C. Silverman Executive Producer Anthony C. Metchie Cinematographer Robert Lawrenson Film Editing Michael Neilson Original Music Errin Lally Casting Annalese Tilling Casting Jim Cliffe Production Design Moe Curtin Art Director Gracey Burnett Set Decoration Kelsey Baran Costume Design