John Putch Director Ginna Claire Mason Maggie Actor Derek Klena John Actor Eve Plumb Harriet Actor Ann-Margret Grandma Margret Actor Byron Jennings Grant Bingham Actor Tiffany Denise Hobbs Alice Actor Stephen DeRosa Frank Actor Tommy Bayiokos Orchestral Drummer Actor Larissa Schmitz Janet Actor Carolyn McCormick Elisabeth Bingham Actor Elle Graper Lucy Actor Dylan S. Wallach Ben Actor Lucia Giannetta Sofia's Mom Actor Michael Brian Dunn Mr. Matthews Actor Sinem Gulturk Ava Actor Erica Dorfler Gimbals Clerk Actor Caitlin McAvoy Waitress Actor Ruth Gottschall Rose Actor Lisa Helmi Johanson Kitty Actor Tom Stratford Sofia's Dad Actor Donald Wayne Grandpa John Actor Sara Gallo Sofia Actor Rebecca Ross Bailey Gimbals Mom Actor Sydney Mesher Lillian Actor Hassan Gray Security Guard Actor JoJo Carmichael Peggy Actor Torsten Johnson Maxwell Actor Marlene Mancini Sofia's Grandmother Actor Katie Lynn Johnson Townsperson Actor The Radio City Rockettes Self Julie Sherman Wolfe Screenwriter Tony Glazer Producer Summer Crockett Moore Producer Dustin Rikert Executive Producer Jessica Tuttle Executive Producer Derick V. Underschultz Cinematographer Harry B. Miller III Film Editing Tommy Fields Original Music Tom Lisowski Production Design Dara Wishingrad Art Director Michael Stone Set Decoration Keith Nielsen Costume Design Patricia McCorkle Casting