Jodi Binstock Director Alicia Witt Meg Actor Donald Faison Ted Actor Christina Milian Sal Actor Trevor Donovan Eric Actor Art LaFleur Mr. Barns Actor Damoni Burkhardt Mia Actor Francia Raisa Penny Actor Talia Jackson Lisa Actor Hayden Faraday Teddy Jr. Actor Logan Binstock Veronica , Mary Actor Jackie Moore Jessica Actor Amy Ryder Winnie Actor Alex Ball Poskins Actor Brody Hutzler Hugh Actor Diahnna Nicole Baxter Barb Actor Naomi L. Selfman Screenwriter David Michael Latt Producer David Rimawi Executive Producer