All the Real Girls (2003) - Rotten Tomatoes

All the Real Girls (2003)



Critic Consensus: Has enough honest moments to warrant a look.

All the Real Girls Videos

All the Real Girls Photos

Movie Info

Twenty-two-year-old Paul lives with his mother and works as a mechanic in a sleepy North Carolina mill town. Charming, smart, and unambitious, he has a devoted circle of rowdy friends and a reputation as a callous heartbreaker. When he meets his best friend's sister Noel, fresh from boarding school graduation, the two fall into a perfect, real, but terrifying love.

Watch it now


Patricia Clarkson
as Elvira Fine
Show More Cast

News & Interviews for All the Real Girls

Critic Reviews for All the Real Girls

All Critics (110) | Top Critics (30)

Undisciplined, unfocused, overimprovised and unevenly acted.

June 6, 2003 | Rating: 2/5
Orlando Sentinel
Top Critic

A wise, delicate and immensely touching romance.

April 11, 2003 | Rating: 3/4
Miami Herald
Top Critic

Much of the film, which so much wants to seem natural and unforced, comes off as contrived and slightly precious.

April 10, 2003 | Rating: C
Atlanta Journal-Constitution
Top Critic

The characters in All the Real Girls can seem a little thin ... but the emotions always feel genuine.

April 4, 2003 | Rating: 3/4
Seattle Times
Top Critic

There's something missing from this slowly paced story of young love, like a painting that's still waiting for its subject to be dropped in.

April 4, 2003 | Rating: C+
Denver Rocky Mountain News
Top Critic

A love story for those who cannot tolerate the phoniness of Hollywood romance movies, one that deftly avoids melodrama and manipulation in favor of raw emotion.

April 3, 2003 | Rating: B | Full Review…
Dallas Morning News
Top Critic

Audience Reviews for All the Real Girls



Super Reviewer

A man pursues his friend's sister, a match frowned upon because of his promiscuous past. Paul Schneider delivers a sensitive portrayal of Paul, and his romantic scenes with Zooey Deschanel are quite charming. What I liked about the film was how relateable that relationship was. Typical of indie films, All the Real Girls is filled with long pauses and understated scenes that fail to state much. I also have several plot questions. I have no idea why Noel chooses the person she chooses in the third act, and because we never see Paul being a rake and he never goes back to his old behavior, it's hard to believe all the rumors about his character flaws. Overall, I think I like this film more than it deserves mainly because the two leads seemed like people I know or could know.

Jim Hunter
Jim Hunter

Super Reviewer


What the hell David Gordon Green? You make the highness and the sitter instead of making more films like this?? This is actually a raw powerhouse film that shows how amazing zooey descahnel and Paul schnieder are. The story is simplistic but the acting and the direction of the film are what makes a contemporary classic. Huge fan of this film!

paul oh
paul oh

Super Reviewer

All the Real Girls Quotes

Discussion Forum

Discuss All the Real Girls on our Movie forum!

News & Features